How do I work with a developmental editor?
- A developmental editor addresses big-picture story issues.
- Submit your strongest self-edited draft, not a rough one.
- Expect critique of structure, character, pacing, and more.
- Stay open, ask questions, and engage with the feedback.
- It is a collaboration, not a verdict.
Work with a developmental editor by first submitting the strongest draft you can — self-edit before paying for big-picture editing. Understand their role: they critique structure, plot, character arcs, pacing, and theme, not line-level prose. Receive the editorial letter openly, expecting substantial critique (that is the value), and engage with it: ask clarifying questions, discuss disagreements respectfully, and decide which suggestions to take. Treat it as a collaboration toward a stronger book, not a judgment of your worth. Clear communication and openness make the relationship productive.
Chapter i·Why it matters
Developmental editing is one of the most valuable (and expensive) investments in a book, and getting the most from it depends on the author's preparation and mindset. Understanding the editor's big-picture role, submitting a strong draft, and engaging openly with substantial critique is what turns the investment into a transformed manuscript. Knowing it is a collaboration — and that hard feedback is the point — helps authors work productively with a developmental editor rather than defensively, maximizing the book's improvement.
Chapter ii·What to include
- A strong, self-edited draft submitted.
- Understanding of the big-picture role.
- Openness to substantial critique.
- Clarifying questions and respectful discussion.
- Authorial judgment on which notes to take.
- A collaborative mindset.
Chapter iii·Example
An author self-edits her novel thoroughly before sending it to a developmental editor. She receives a detailed editorial letter flagging a weak midpoint and a flat arc, and rather than getting defensive, she asks clarifying questions and discusses the fixes. Engaging openly with the big-picture critique transforms her manuscript — the return on a well-managed developmental edit.
WriteLoom keeps your manuscript and editorial feedback together, so working with a developmental editor stays organized.
See WriteLoom